Fish Lake is stocked with rainbow trout, tiger trout and Chinook salmon. Recently, 900 large rainbows averaging 14- to 16-inches long were stocked to add to the fishery. Brook trout also are available.

Trolling lures like a flatfish or a wedding ring/worm combo, as well casting flies can be very effective in the fall months at Fish Lake. A portion of the rainbow trout have external parasites called copepods that can be scraped off the fish prior to cooking. Fish parasites do not pose a threat to people when cooked properly. Fish Lake is currently at 51 percent capacity.